Tag

Acne Scars

Acne scars — including ice pick, boxcar, and rolling types — form when severe breakouts damage the deeper layers of skin. Professional treatments like RF microneedling, laser resurfacing, and collagen-stimulating injectables can significantly improve texture and tone.

See all treatments

Book nowCall us

The Four Acne Scar Types

Not all acne scars are the same — and treating the wrong type with the wrong method produces worse results, not better ones. Acne scarring falls into four clinical categories, each defined by how the skin responded to inflammatory damage during the breakout. The first step at a Desert Bloom consultation is identifying which type (or combination of types) is present, because that classification determines the entire treatment plan.

PIH vs. Atrophic Scars — Two Different Problems

The most common error in acne scar treatment — from patients and providers alike — is treating every dark or imperfect mark after acne as the same problem. PIH (post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation) is a color problem: the skin surface is flat, smooth, and structurally intact, but the melanocytes misfired and left a brown or red mark. An atrophic scar is a structural deficit: the dermis lost collagen and the surface is pitted, depressed, or uneven in texture. These two conditions often occur at the same site after a severe breakout, which is where the confusion compounds — a patient can have both a pitted boxcar scar and overlying PIH discoloration in the same spot.

The treatment path splits completely at this fork. PIH responds to brightening chemistry — chemical peels with alpha hydroxy acids or mandelic acid, lightening serums, PRX-T33 and Dermaquest peel protocols for darker skin tones. For Fitzpatrick IV–VI patients with PIH, ablative laser and IPL are contraindicated: they add thermal or light-based inflammation to already-reactive melanocytes and can worsen the hyperpigmentation significantly. The non-laser brightening route is both safer and more effective for this presentation. Atrophic scars, by contrast, need collagen remodeling — RF Microneedling, Erbium, CO2, or Bellafill filler. No amount of brightening treatment will fill a pitted depression. When both co-exist, the atrophic scar treatment usually leads; collagen remodeling often improves the overlying PIH as a secondary benefit, and any remaining discoloration is addressed with a peel series afterward.

Treatment Options for Acne Scars at Desert Bloom

Most acne scar plans at Desert Bloom start with RF Microneedling and layer in targeted modalities based on scar sub-type, skin tone, and how the skin responds over time. The five primary routes below each have a distinct role and a clear patient profile. One option — Bellafill — is worth singling out because it is the only FDA-approved injectable filler specifically for atrophic acne scars, which makes it a different category from the energy-based treatments.

RF Microneedling (Virtue RF) — First-Line for Most Atrophic ScarsFor rolling and boxcar acne scars — and mixed presentations — RF Microneedling is where Dr. Borakowski typically starts. Radiofrequency energy travels through microneedles directly into the dermis to remodel scar tissue without ablating the surface. That distinction matters for skin tone: it is safe and effective across Fitzpatrick I–VI, including darker skin tones where CO2 laser carries real post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation risk. Most patients need 3–4 sessions spaced 4–6 weeks apart. Clinical studies show 50–80% improvement in rolling and boxcar scars over a series.Best for: rolling + boxcar — all Fitz I–VI, mixed presentations · See RF Microneedling →

CO2 Laser — Deep Ice Pick and Severe BoxcarWhen scars are deep and mature and RF Microneedling alone has not been enough, CO2 laser is the escalation. Ablation removes damaged tissue layer by layer and triggers the most aggressive collagen remodeling response available non-surgically. Reserved for Fitzpatrick I–III — surface ablation carries real PIH risk in darker skin. Requires 7–14 days downtime but produces the highest single-session improvement ceiling for severe acne scarring. An escalation tool, not a starting point.Best for: deep ice pick, severe boxcar — Fitz I–III only · See CO2 Laser →

Microneedling with PRP — Newer Scars and BridgingFor acne scars still in early stages (under 12 months old), mild surface texture, or as a bridge between heavier RF or laser sessions. Microneedling creates controlled collagen-induction microchannels; platelet-rich plasma drawn from the patient’s own blood is applied topically to enhance healing. Less powerful than RF Microneedling in the dermis — not appropriate for deep pitting — but a gentle and safe starting point across all Fitzpatrick types with minimal downtime.Best for: newer scars (<12 mo), mild texture, bridging — all Fitz · See Microneedling →

Bellafill (PMMA) — FDA-Approved Injectable for Atrophic Acne ScarsBellafill is the only FDA-approved dermal filler specifically indicated for atrophic acne scars. It contains PMMA (polymethylmethacrylate) microspheres suspended in a collagen gel — the collagen gel provides immediate volume correction while the PMMA microspheres stimulate the body’s own ongoing collagen production at the scar floor. Best suited for distensible boxcar and rolling scars where the volume deficit is the primary problem, and for patients who have plateaued with energy-based treatment. Results are long-lasting. Downtime is minimal — injection-site bruising possible.Best for: distensible boxcar + rolling, scars plateaued on energy devices — all Fitz · See Bellafill →

Custom Chemical Peel — PIH and Surface DiscolorationWhen the post-acne concern is flat brown or red discoloration rather than a textural pit — or when PIH persists after a resurfacing series — a chemical peel addresses what lasers were not designed for. AHA-based and mandelic acid formulations work at the epidermal level to even out pigment residue. Safe across all Fitzpatrick types at appropriate peel depth. An adjunct for the atrophic scar route, or a standalone treatment for pure PIH cases where the surface is smooth.Best for: PIH, flat discoloration, color concern after resurfacing — all Fitz · See Chemical Peel →

Compare Acne Scar Treatment Options

Safety, Skin Type, and Timing

Acne scar treatment has hard rules around skin tone, scar age, and whether active acne is still present. The most common clinical errors are treating with ablative laser on Fitzpatrick IV–VI skin (adding a color problem to a texture problem), treating while breakouts are still active (generating new scars and inflammation during treatment), and treating scars that are still remodeling (under six months old). These three situations each require a different approach before aesthetic scar treatment is appropriate.

Working With Dr. Borakowski on Acne Scars

Dr. Natalya Borakowski, NMD has treated acne scarring for over twenty years, and the clinical judgment required here — which scar type, which skin tone, which treatment in which sequence — is the kind of pattern recognition that compounds with experience. A consultation that skips the classification step and goes straight to recommending “laser” or “microneedling” without mapping the sub-type, the Fitzpatrick number, and the scar’s age is a consultation that will produce inconsistent outcomes. She starts every acne scar appointment with the classification before any treatment plan is discussed.

She is also deliberate about contraindications. Patients with active acne are told to stabilize breakouts first. Darker-skin patients with PIH are routed to the non-laser brightening protocol — not pushed toward ablative laser because it is higher-revenue or more familiar. Scars that are still maturing are counseled to wait. The goal is a plan that is right for the scar in front of her, not a standard package applied to every patient who books a scar consult.

Medically reviewed byDr. Natalya Borakowski, NMDFounder, Desert Bloom Skincare

“Acne scars are the one area where I see the most mismatched treatments — laser on the wrong skin tone, energy devices on scars that need filler, brightening peels on pitted skin that needs collagen remodeling. The consult is where we sort that out. Most patients see meaningful improvement when we treat the right problem with the right tool.”